1
Best Pizza in Appleton, WI
46 results · page 1 of 2Looking for the best pizza in Appleton, WI? Here are 46 local businesses, ranked by ratings and reviews from real customers, then by their online presence (website, social profiles, how many sources list them) and how complete their details are. How we rank · Updated November 2026.
Best Pizza in nearby cities:Kaukauna 6Little Chute 3Kimberly 3Grand Chute 2De Pere 1Oneida 1Seymour 1Greenville 1Buchanan 1Black Creek 1
Looking for pizza in Appleton, WI?Tell us about the job in one minute. We show you the best matches right away, and businesses on Lokaldex can get back to you.
Get quotes2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Frequently asked questions
What are the best pizza in Appleton, WI?
Based on customer ratings and reviews on Lokaldex, the top pizza in Appleton, WI right now are Little Caesars Pizza, Nick-n-Willy's Pizza and Broken Tree Taproom and Pizza.
How many pizza are there in Appleton, WI?
Lokaldex lists 46 pizza in Appleton, WI.
How are the best pizza in Appleton, WI ranked?
Businesses are ranked by their average rating, weighted by how many reviews they have, then by their online presence (website, social media profiles, how many data sources list them) and how complete their details are (phone, address, hours). Businesses cannot pay to change their place in this list; paid placements are shown separately and labeled Sponsored.
How can I add my business to this list?
If your business is in Appleton, WI, you can list it free or claim your existing listing to add your hours, services, photos and website.